Finally getting my MP3 player up and going, I decide I need content for it. That means MP3 files. I have, for unknown reasons, not availed myself of Apple's iTunes store; a dollar a song just seems high to me. (Ed's note: yes, I know it's only 99 cents--a dastardly psychological trick I caught onto many moons ago.)
It should be noted as well that this dollar will only buy you songs less than ten minutes in length. There's no $1.25 or $1.75 for longer works; you have to buy the album if you want the song. This lack of compromise seems oddly disjointed. But the Apple music store is hugely successful, so perhaps I'm the one who is wrong.
A dollar a song also applies no matter how short a song is. Check They Might Be Giant's
Apollo 18 album and look at the list price. If you don't have iTunes, I'll spare you the suspense: while most of their albums are ten dollars, that one retails for a wholloping $25. The reason? "Fingertips," a song-suite made up of twenty-one songs. You might think
Fair enough,that's a lot of songs there, unless I tell you that most of those songs are under ten seconds each. If you want "I Heard A Sound," it's going to cost you a dollar for four seconds of audio. Granted, nothing is perfect and I think Apple on the whole does a very good job. It just isn't what I want. I'm also not really happy that you can't browse their store without their application.
Be that as it may, the next bit of this entry is What I Did Instead. I joined a music service.
Three of them, to be exact. Here's what they be:
eMusic. Taking advantage of an offer that they have, apparently, decided was too good to be true, I got fifty free downloads for signing up. (It has since been dropped to twenty-five.) I promptly used up a lot of these downloading Colin Newman's first three solo albums. That should tell you why I like eMusic's selection.
But they've got other good stuff, too. Henry Cow, The Residents, Metal Urbain, lots and lots of classical recordings (most on the Naxos label, but also some BIS and Harmoni Mundi as well). You won't find the Beatles or Michael Jackson here, but you will find a lot of second-tier obscure stuff. I got the Art Bears'
Hopes and Fears and the first Ralph album by Tuxedomoon, as well as bunches and bunches of other stuff.
You can cancel the free trial and keep what you downloaded, so if I wanted, that was fifty free songs right there. (There is no length restriction on downloads; if you found fifty hour-long tracks, you could have downloaded them all.) But I went ahead and joined the service anyway, and now I get ninety downloads a month. There is a lot here to keep me busy, and if I run out of downloads one month, I can buy a "booster pack" and get more.
There are some downsides to eMusic. One of the most galling is that some albums are incomplete--the tracks are listed as part of the running order, but you can't download them. Apparently, this gets fixed sometimes, other times it does not. The reasons range from lost rights (in song or performer) to bad files being removed. As an album person, I find it frustrating. As a listener, I'm baffled that I can download part one of Charles Wuorinen's
Time's Encomium, but part two is unavailable.
The second drawback is that the selection, as noted, can be pretty obscure and the artists are not always represented by their best work. Pere Ubu is here, but not their great first few albums; there's one Firesign Theatre CD, and it’s not one of their classics from the seventies. The more obscure the artist, the better off you may be. The Residents, for example, are well represented with some of their best stuff.
One also has to be wary of the K-Tel syndrome, especially with more popular stuff: some of it is re-recordings, not the original records.
I also joined
LegalSounds. Gosh, with a name like
that, what could possibly go wrong? For this one, you pay a certain amount into an account balance, and then download songs which removes nine cents from this balance. Most albums cost a dollar, some less. There’s a lot of stuff here—the Beatles, Rolling Stones, Bob Dylan, David Bowie, Pink Floyd, King Crimson, to name some of the larger entries. Conversely, cultish folk like the Residents are sparsely represented with only two entries. They did have
Pink Flag, however, and lots of Van Der Graaf Generator. There’s a lot of stuff, and it’s cheap.
The obvious downside is, can this possibly be
legal? Apparently it is, somehow, but I can’t imagine how. A second downside is that there are missing tracks here, but unlike eMusic, they don’t tell you what you’re not getting. David Bowie’s
Scary Monsters CD is missing the last track, “It’s No Game, Part 2.” Hardly an unsung classic, but still, I like completeness.
AllCoolMusic is the final service I joined. Unlike the others, this isn’t an online store—it’s a hub where folks Kazaa each other songs. (You can't find this out until you join, a drawback of most of these stores.) This one I’m sure is dubious, and I have tended to shy away. There really isn’t a way to browse for stuff, like eMusic or LegalSounds; you pretty much have to know what you want.
All three of these services require you to install their own download engine, which downloads the songs (duh) and ticks off your counter (money or downloads remaining). In all three cases for these downloads, I chose an old PC which I wouldn’t miss if it blew up with spyware, malware or viruses. Regular scanning has revealed no problems, but I was still sweating when I tried these things out.
As noted, most of these services require you to join before you can even browse for stuff. So you really have no idea if you’re going to find that obscure album by Gilbert and Lewis or not, until you’ve entered an email address and a password (you can get free email all over the place; I’m sure I don’t have to tell you about that). This is, shall we say, pretty damned annoying and it makes me unhappy at the start. Note: you don’t have to spend any money, or even give them a credit card when you join, so you’re really just activating an account. But an account I may never use if I don’t like the selection? Oh well. (Sometimes you can click on “Login” and it will give you a search page without an account, but this doesn’t work all the time.)
Bottom line: I like eMusic, I’m a bit dubious about LegalSounds, and I’m pretty sure AllCoolMusic is something I should stay away from.
Your mileage may vary.